Quantitative and Citizen Literacy
through
Key Environmental Issues
of our time.




Harel Barzilai
Salisbury University



Joint Mathematics Meetings
January, 2009.

Math 190 - Liberal Arts Mathematics (satisfies SU's Gen Ed)
      Flavor: Quantitative Literacy and Environmental Issues

Background
  • Collaboration on QL/NAC → curricular development
  • Additional curricular development during 06/07 Sabbatical
  • Course first offered Spr 08; next offering: Spr 09

  • Goal: Enhance QL, with focus on environ. issues. Philosophy informed by:
    "[QL] involves sophisticated thinking with elementary mathematics more often than elementary thinking with sophisticated mathematics" MAA's Achieving Quantitative Literacy: An Urgent Challenge for Higher Education by Lynn Arthur Steen

  • A demanding course: open-ended problems and in-class investigations; non-linear, spiral learning, and integrative.
  • A "Friendly" course: Groupwork, group projects, class discussion.

  • No Textbook; multitude of handouts, activities, longer explorations, readings

    Fixed Portions:
    Class Attendance &
    Participation in Class
    10%
    Two Math Skills Tests 20%
    HW Write-ups (suppl w/quizzes) 10%
    Capstone Project Presentation 5%
     
    Student-Chosen Percent (within given range) for:
    Professional Expository
    Mathematics Journal (PEMJ)
    15-25%
    Group Capstone Project 15-25%
    Final Exam 15-25%

    Some of Topics Covered..

  • Comfort with back-of-envelope estimation

    Ex: Amt. of scratchpaper from tests not recycled, per semester, at SU? US?

  • Comfort with large numbers
  • Units and conversions
  • Ratios, proportions.

    Ex: If the observable universe were an Earth-size sphere, how big would our galaxy be? If our galaxy had Earth's radius, how big would the Sun be?

    Ex: Number of miles driven in the US, gasoline consumption in the US (complex to compare stats cited in two or more articles.




  • Percents ('elementary' & more 'advanced')

    Common Errors with Percents:

    "Since the industrial revolution, population has increased from 1 billion to 6 billion" described as "an increase of ____%"

  • Mayor of a major city:
    "65% of energy is wasted in the cooling system..if we have locally done energy it's 15%..so if we could wave a magic wand and all [UK]energy was coming from local sources you'd reduce your fossil-fuel consumption by 50 per cent"
    Graphical literacy
  • Interpreting, creating/labeling graphs;
  • comparing two or more graphs
  • Effects of scaling/units chosen. :

    Ex: Worldwide CO2 over ~several (sine-line but increasing) vs. over ~1000 yrs ("e^t?") vs over ~100k yrs vs 400k or 800k yrs.

    Ex:World Population: Level Vs % Growth Vs. Annual Change

    Above two also Re: f(t) vs f'(t) vs f''(t)

    Effects of Quantities being compared

    Ex: Drive M miles per year, use G gallons per year. Gas costs C $/gal, car gets E mpg. HW exercises in which values are given for two of these; third is indep, fourth is dep variable. Which are lines? Which are nonlinear? Why? Interpretation?

    Qualitative descriptions of graphs
        E.g. "decreasing, concave up" or, "increasing at a decreasing rate"

  • "Increasing at increasing rate" ⇎ "Exponential"
  • Qualitative shapes of curves: lessons (e.g. "diminishing returns")
  • Qualitative versus quantitative (e.g. "diminishing returns" ⇎ "not worth it")

    Log functions: the pH scale.
        Ocean Acidification from CO2 emissions.

    Acidic concentration increased by 30% since industrial revolution. Effect on pH =___?           (Ans: about 0.11)

    Backwards: by 2100 pH could be 0.3 to 0.5 lower than today. Assume 0.37 lower than today, which is ___lower than pre-industrial. What perc. increase in acidity, preindustrial to 2100, would this rep?      ≈300% of the old conc (200% increase)

    Rates
    ♦ Computing Average rates of change;
    •    Instantaneous vs average rates of change;
    •    How the two are related.

    ♦ Value vs. rate
    •Peak oil not same as "no more oil is left"
    •Rather, maximum rate of extraction in e.g. bbl/yr

    Units: Oil depletion of "3 mbd" in press refers to decrease rate of (3million barrels/day) / year

    Proportions (More Advanced, with modeling)
    Example: HW reading and exercises based on What's Your Consumption Factor? by Pulitzer-Prize winning writer Jared Diamon, writing in NY Times:

    "Per capita consumption rates in China are still about 11 times below ours, but let's suppose they rise to [US's consumption] level. Let's also make things easy by imagining that nothing else happens to increase world consumption -- that is, no other country increases its consumption, all national populations (including China's) remain unchanged and immigration ceases. China's catching up alone would double world consumption rates."[emph added]

    Exercise: Assuming the US consumes roughly 25% of the world's resources (oil, etc) and using populations of 300M and 1330M for US and China respectively, find a way to confirm the "would double" above (phrased in more detail for students)

    Slopes of lines; "slopes" of nonlinear functions

    Looking at CO2: Graphs with different scales
    Looking at CO2: Graphs versus numerical data

    Using recent data for last ~60 yrs

    Contrast with example from a calculus book:
    Linear model for CO2 as a function of the year:
        A. By connecting the first and last of the given points:
        C(t) = 1.5545t - 2739.21


        B. Using Linear Regression on Calculator:
         C(t) = 1.55192t - 2734.55

    "Fancier tool" got a "tiny" difference. What lessons do students learn? Worse, non-linearity of C(t) is at the very heart of env. issue.

  • Peak Oil: Value of f(t) vs Rate of change of f(t)
    Peak oil not same as "no more oil is left" ; rather, maximum rate of extraction in barrels per year. (units -- Oil depletion of "3 mbd" in articles refers to decrease of (3million barrels per day)/year

    Key Concept: Areas under graphs of functions.
    Important case: Area under the graph of f(t), t=time.

    Some Key examples: Driving a car ; CO2 emissions; Peak oil